Amazon says my product may be inauthentic and my invoices are old. Will they count?

Often they won't. Amazon staff on the Seller Forums have said an acceptable invoice has an issue date "within the past 365 days before the receipt of the performance notification." So a product can be completely genuine and still be hard to prove, if the only paper behind it is older than that window.
"It's real" isn't proof
It's the most honest thing a seller can say to Amazon. On its own, it isn't enough.
At the end of October, a seller posted on a seller forum that Amazon wanted invoices for two of their ASINs. They mostly sell new old stock, and by their account both products have been out of production for 15 to 20 years. There's no supplier left to invoice anything.
They sent what they had: purchase records, card statements and tracking. Then they put the store on vacation and wrote that they expect to be done on Amazon.
What Amazon has said about invoices
Amazon staff on the Seller Forums describe an acceptable invoice as one with an issue date "within the past 365 days before the receipt of the performance notification," with enough quantity to cover sales of each cited ASIN over the past 365 days.
When a seller asked about older stock, an Amazon staff reply on the Seller Forums said an invoice outside that window "would not be considered valid and our team will reject it."
From our experience, an older invoice has sometimes been accepted with the right case, but that's never something to count on.
The window counts back from the notice
Here's the part we'd want every seller to sit with. The window doesn't start the day you bought the stock. It counts back 365 days from the day the notice arrives.
So the stock you've held longest is the stock that's hardest to document.
The Black Friday risk most sellers don't picture
From our experience, this is where honest sellers get caught. Everyone worries about fakes at Black Friday. We worry more about the real product sitting on old paper. Genuine and documented aren't the same thing, and the invoice is the part Amazon can check.
Black Friday is November 27, and clearance week is when the oldest stock sells fastest. That's exactly when the oldest paper carries the most weight.
What about a product nobody makes anymore?
How Amazon treats a product with no supplier left at all, we couldn't find in any current Amazon statement, and we won't guess.
Our take
Clearing old stock at Black Friday is smart business. Just know which of those units are covered by recent paper and which are riding on an invoice from another season. That's a short look today, not a crisis in December.
One first step for this week: for each ASIN you plan to clear at Black Friday, write down the date of the newest supplier invoice that covers it.
If an authenticity complaint is already open on your account, talk to Market Wize. We're on your side, and we'll look at it with you, always legally and within Amazon's policies.
FAQ
How recent does an invoice need to be for an Amazon authenticity complaint?
Amazon staff on the Seller Forums have described an acceptable invoice as having an issue date "within the past 365 days before the receipt of the performance notification."
Will Amazon accept an invoice older than 365 days?
An Amazon staff reply on the Seller Forums said an invoice outside that window "would not be considered valid and our team will reject it."
Does the 365 days count from when I bought the stock?
No. As we read Amazon's wording, the window counts back from the day the notice arrives, not forward from the purchase.
What if the product is no longer made and there's no supplier?
We couldn't find a current Amazon statement on that, and we won't guess. If you're in that spot, talk to Market Wize.
Amazon changes, explained in your inbox
A short email when Amazon changes something that matters to sellers, with our read on what it means for your business.